Comparative Analysis between the Constitutional Processes in Egypt and Tunisia - Lessons Learnt. Overview of the Constitutional Situation in Libya
The 2014 Constitutions of Egypt and Tunisia, though enacted at the same time and as a consequence of very similar revolutionary forces, are different in style and content. Egypt has fallen back to the structures of the 1971 Constitution and will likely experience further restoration of the authoritarian presidentialism. The Armed Forces continue to play a dominant background role in the political and constitutional life of the country. Tunisia seems to have embraced a new constitutional paradigm that is based on a modern approach to human rights protection and a balanced institutional framework that provides for substantial checks and balances between the three branches of government. The constitutional drafting process in Libya is overshadowed by a pronounced lack of security, the absence of functioning state institutions, societal fragmentation, and the uneven distribution of natural wealth. National reconciliation is a key precondition of successful political and constitutional transition but the process has to date been a very difficult one. There are indications, however, that stakeholders in Libya are trying to build consensus on important aspects of the process. The 1951 Constitution, based on a federal framework, offers the best conceptual framework for the recently elected Constituent Assembly. Unlike Egypt and Tunisia, Libya might opt for a parliamentary form of government rather than a semi-presidential system.
Analiză aprofundată
Autor extern
Jörg FEDTKE (Tulane University Law School, New Orleans, Louisiana, USA)
Despre acest document
Tipul publicației
Domeniul tematic
Cuvânt-cheie
- Africa
- conjunctură politică
- democratizare
- DREPT
- drepturile individului
- drepturile omului
- Egipt
- GEOGRAFIE
- geografie economică
- geografie politică
- izvoarele şi ramurile dreptului
- Libia
- POLITICĂ
- politică şi securitate publică
- putere executivă şi administraţie publică
- regim prezidențial
- relație executiv-legislativ
- revizuirea constituției
- separație a puterilor
- sistem parlamentar
- situație politică
- Tunisia